It was old, the keyboard was falling apart, and the finish looked like cracked shoe polish.
My father’s Steinway was left to me when he passed, and I was ready to let it go. Although parts of the action had been restored, its current state made me sad. It had been sitting in a sun-filled window for decades, and the only maintenance it ever received was an occasional visit from the local tuner.
“You can’t let the Steinway go,” my children said. “It’s our childhood,” they reminded me. “Your father owned nothing,” noted my husband. “Use the life insurance money to restore the Steinway.” So began the Steinway’s journey from Daniel’s Manhattan apartment on 84th Street, to the workshops of two loving artisans, Brian, of Brooklyn’s Big Wrench Piano, and Marco, of Long Island’s Marco’s Art of Restoration. Brian would re-build the action and keyboard, while Marco would take on the mammoth job of stripping and restoring the finish.
Needless to say, this endeavor quickly went over budget and involved God knows how many phone calls and forms to insurance companies regarding the Steinway’s removal from Daniel’s apartment building. When it finally went on its way, there was time to think: about Daniel, about the piano, about the gift of music he left us all.
I’ve written about this in my essay, The Painting and the Photograph:
One of the challenges of my relationship with Daniel was his extraordinary gift at the piano. I was given lessons, but I was lazy and more interested in ballet, and in the back of my mind, I knew I would never, much to Alla’s disappointment, be able to play like Daniel. I would later write an essay called Why Not? about my checkered history with the piano. To his credit, Daniel didn’t seem to care. Piano was his joy and his cross to bear, and he had no interest in inflicting it on me.
In Why Not? I wrote about childhood piano lessons:
This is how it played out. My mother would find a teacher. For the first few weeks all would go according to plan. Then, after several months, the slide downward would begin. I wouldn’t practice, the teacher wouldn’t get anywhere with me, my mother would be called in. “Mrs. Gutoff,” the teacher would proclaim, “I really can’t do anything with this child. She refuses to practice, she doesn’t seem interested, she can’t work.” My mother, loath to believe there was anything wrong with her special snowflake child, would turn around and blame the teacher: “Well, you’re obviously a bad teacher if you can’t engage her in music!” and off we’d go.
Down the street, to another teacher, where the whole scene would play out all over again. It was such a charade that I actually began to enjoy the drama of it, especially the fact that it had nothing to do with playing the piano. It was fun watching the teacher tell my mother what a terrible student I was; but the real pleasure was watching my mother tell the teacher it was her fault. How perfect for me. No work, no consequences. And free entertainment to boot.
There were three inherent problems with this scenario. First, I had a stage mother with grand dreams. Of course, those dreams had nothing to do with me. Second, I had no interest in playing the piano; it was my mother who, as a result of the first problem, wanted me to play. Third, because I had no interest in playing the piano, I turned the whole thing into an entertainment for my own delight. It therefore became something completely different from what it set out to be.
In The Painting and the Photograph, I reflected on leaving lessons:
“You’ll be sorry,” Alla chided, when I announced I was no longer studying piano in my 20s. When she passed away, I was 37 years of age, and I did regret having quit. In her honor, and now Daniel’s, I found a marvelous teacher who I have now been studying with for over twenty years. In addition to re-connecting with the piano, this gave me something to once again share with Daniel. “What are you working on?” he would ask. In a rare, brave moment, I would occasionally even play for him. My inadequacies were always matched by his enthusiasm. “That was wonderful,” he would say.
One day I got a call from Brian. He’d spoken with Marco.
“Are you ready?” he asked. I sat down.
“The piano is mahogany.”
I tried to process his words. My father’s piano, the beat-up Steinway he’d been playing since the 1930s, was MAHOGANY?! Multiple thoughts flooded my brain: WHO painted it? WHY? Did Daniel KNOW?
The waiting game was now in full force. I could not imagine what this instrument, the one both Daniel and I grew up with, would look like. Then, delivery day came: two men quickly brought the Steinway into my house, assembled it and, just as quickly, left. I burst into tears. It was stunning. And Daniel never got to see it.
One of my favorite childhood moments with Daniel was when I’d ask about a piece of music I’d heard. All I had to do was hum a classical melody and, no matter how popular or obscure the piece, he’d identify it, complete with opus number and major or minor key.
Lately, I’ve been listening to French flute music and a glorious piece called Serenade a Mabel, by Benjamin Godard.
“Dad, have you ever heard of…?”